How Beyonce and Jay-Z Defy Western Art Tradition in ‘Apeshit’ Video
Two black stars claim one of the centerpieces of white European culture in ‘Everything Is Love’ clip
In the video forÂ BeyoncÃ©Â andÂ Jay-Z’s “Apeshit,” the first visual from the pair’sÂ surprise joint albumÂ Everything Is Love, the two stars romp through the Louvre in Paris, seizing center stage in a high-culture palace that ”“ like most Western art museums ”“ historically made little room for non-white artists.
Some of their mission involves the strategic highlighting of non-white images already in the Louvre. BeyoncÃ© and Jay-Z rap in front of an Egyptian sphinx, and in galleries filled mostly with neo-classical French paintings ”“ white artists, white subjects ”“ the cameraÂ singles out black faces. (The video is directed by Ricky Saiz, who also helmedÂ theÂ “Yonce” videoÂ from BeyoncÃ©’s eponymous 2013 album.) Viewers catch brief glimpses of a pair of black figures in Paolo Veronese’s painting “The Wedding at Cana,” where Jesus turned water into wine, as well as a quick look at Marie-Guillemine Benoist’s “Portrait d’une NÃ©gresse,” a depiction of a black woman staring guilelessly back at the viewer.
But theÂ Where’s Waldo?Â moments highlighting black figures are fleeting ”“ the possibilities for this in the Louvre, or any major Western art museum, are limited from the start. So BeyoncÃ© and Jay-Z set about interjecting blackness into a space that has never placed much value on it, claiming one of the centerpieces of European culture with gleeful defiance. They frequently film themselves moving in opposition to the frozen stillness of paintings by Jacques-Louis David, a French neoclassical artist whose workÂ ”“ like “The Oath of the Horatii” and “Madame RÃ©camier” ”“ invokes the Greco-Roman tradition.
Much of the potency of the “Apeshit” video comes from the contrasts drawn between the “white” art on the walls and the black women on the gallery floors. In front of David’s “The Consecration of the Emperor Napoleon and the Coronation of Empress JosÃ©phine,” a court scene of relentless white extravagance, BeyoncÃ© and eight black dancers hold hands and begin to dance. It takes just a few synchronized sashays to upstage David’s massive painting, replacing an ornate symbol of white authority with a celebration of black bodies in motion. The Louvre’s stature depends on people believing that “The Coronation of Empress JosÃ©phine” is the art, but the eye tells a different story ”“ hanging behind BeyoncÃ© and her dancers, the painting is reduced to wallpaper.
Later, BeyoncÃ© and Jay-Z stand in front of the Venus de Milo, one of the Louvre’s most well-known statues, the kind of white marble creation that is synonymous with European high-art. The statue is inert and famously arm-less; BeyoncÃ© is fluid, fierce and in perpetual motion.
It’s not only BeyoncÃ© who eclipses the art. Just a few scenes before the singer’s victory over Venus de Milo, a line of her dancers sway back and forth in the foreground while another white marble statue, “The Winged Victory of Samothrace,” looms inertly behind them.Â Everything Is Love‘s cover image, which also comes from the “Apeshit” video, casually one-ups the “Mona Lisa”: A dancer carefully tends to a black man’s hair while Leonardo da Vinci’s beauty languishes in the distance.
Jay-Z’s role in the new clip is more limited ”“ the rapper stands around in pastel suit jackets, gallantly letting his wife do all the work, wrecking frame after frame. He relies on his lyrics to make the points that BeyoncÃ© and her dancers drive home visually. The beat, co-produced by Pharrell Williams, splits the difference between the zaniness of Rae Sremmurd’s “Black Beatles” and the crushing momentum of Future’s “Move That Dope;” Jay-Z raps quickly and cleanly, often while standing in front of ThÃ©odore GÃ©ricault’s painting “The Raft of the Medusa,” throwing darts at traditional bastions of white-ness outside the museum world, including the NFL and the Grammys. When he raps, “I said no to the Super Bowl / You need me, I don’t need you,” the camera flashes to a line of young black men taking a knee, alluding to Colin Kaepernick and other players’ decision to kneel during the national anthem to protest police brutality.