Paul Simonâ€™s Restless Journey
How a musical perfectionist from Queens who agonises over every lyric became one of the most important artists of his generation
Late afternoon on a winterâ€™s day, and Paul Simon is hard at work with his eight-member band in a rented rehearsal studio not far from his home in New Canaan, Connecticut. Simon is preparing the group for a tour of smallish venues in support of So Beautiful or So What, his 11th solo album. Like all his records, So Beautiful is a gumbo of intricately assembled tones and chords, and because Simon recorded the 10 songs largely on his own, the band has been gathering to learn them all. Back before 1970, when Simon and Art Garfunkel decided to get themselves free of one another, the two childhood friends from Queens were known as musical perfectionists, so immersed in sounds that they would spend weeks in the studio recording a single new song like â€˜The Boxer.â€™ Simon is now nearly six birthdays past the morning when his old friend Paul McCartney telephoned to say, â€œIâ€™m sorry, but this has to be done,â€ and sang him â€˜When Iâ€™m 64,â€™ but nothing has changed about his approach to music. Which explains why his percussionist and lead guitarist are currently on their on their hands and knees, huddled together, ears pressed to a large speaker, trying identify that mysterious tapping noise.
Simon usually comes to rehearsals in a blue, brushed-felt fedora and a hooded sweatshirt, and his public reputation is for being a bit blue and hooded himself. â€œThe only interesting thing is the work,â€ he says. At the moment, the band is deep into â€˜Rewrite,â€™ a deceptively quiet song on So Beautiful that engages with the intense desire people have to go back and change troubling things that have happened in their past. When he writes, Simon begins with rhythm or melody, and the lyrics come last. Sound is what most interests him, which is why, when you hear a classic line from an old song, like â€œthe Boy in the Bubble and the baby with the baboon heart,â€ the words are so rhythmic that they very nearly are the rhythm. Here in the studio, the challenge for the band is recreating all the sounds that Simon has layered into his new songs. There are guitars and drums, more recondite instruments like the glass harp and angklung, and ambient noises that Simonâ€™s wife, the singer Edie Brickell, recorded on a small digital tape machine during a family trip to Africa: humming insects, tent zippers, grunting wildebeests. â€œI put the wildebeest in just to change the sound,â€ Simon says. â€œNobodyâ€™ll notice, but changing the textures makes you hear more clearly. Without these sounds, itâ€™s like Iâ€™m just playing a guitar in a room, which I donâ€™t like. So I put in ambience. I put in the African night.â€
All this is no problem for the virtuosos in Simonâ€™s band. But what is that faint thock, thock, thock everyone hears when the sound engineer plays back the track from the album? Even Simon isnâ€™t sure. â€œIt doesnâ€™t have to be exactly like the record,â€ he tells the perplexed musicians. â€œItâ€™s fine so long as we keep it simple and a little weird.â€ But as the band practices â€˜Rewrite,â€™ Simon keeps stopping them, on average, every 20 seconds, to refine the number. His attention to detail is such that during rehearsals for his musical The Capeman, he kept the entire company waiting for half an hour while he explored the theatre, testing the air for the ideal spot to place a gourd player. Comparing his approach to writing music with that of Paul McCartney, Simon says, â€œHe doesnâ€™t think of it in the same way as I do. He wants to capture his impulse. Me, Iâ€™m happy to spend a year and a half on a song. Iâ€™m willing to wrestle until I cry uncle or I beat it. I think that way â€“ I got ya now! Gotcha!â€
Simonâ€™s remnant hair is grey, but otherwise his essential features remain intact: Under the awning of the ever-present hat or baseball cap are those silent eyes, the alert, expressive brows, the chesty boxerâ€™s frame, the oft-pursed lips that indicate a watchful presence. At five foot four, Simon has no illusions about his image as a rock star; he once went through a period when he so disliked his own appearance that he refused to look at photographs of himself. â€œItâ€™s easier not to play the game of rock star when you donâ€™t look like one,â€ says McCartney. â€œHe looks professorial â€“ you can imagine him teaching you literature. The fame game can make people believe their own legends and go out of control. He has in-built protection.â€ In the studio, Simon is dry and deadpan. At one point during rehearsal, Jim Oblon, the youngest member of the band, puts down his drumsticks, moves to the microphone and starts riffing over the melody.
â€œIf I do that, will I get more girls after the show?â€ Oblon asks.
â€œYouâ€™re in the wrong band,â€ Simon tells him. â€œOr at least a decade late.â€
One day not long ago, Donald Fagen, of Steely Dan, who has admired Simonâ€™s work for decades but knows him only slightly, offered up a spontaneous theory of Simonâ€™s childhood. â€œThereâ€™s a certain kind of New York Jew,â€ Fagen began, â€œalmost a stereotype, really, to whom music and baseball are very important. I think it has to do with the parents. The parents are either immigrants or first-generation Americans who felt like outsiders, and assimilation was the key thought â€“ they gravitated to black music and baseball looking for an alternative culture. My parents forced me to get a crew cut; they wanted me to be an astronaut. I wouldnâ€™t be surprised if all thatâ€™s true in Paulâ€™s case.â€
When I recount this to Simon, he says Fagen isnâ€™t far from the truth. Simonâ€™s parents were first-generation American Jews. His mother, Belle, taught at a Queens elementary school, and his father, Lou, was a professional musician who played the bass â€œto put food on the table.â€ They lived on 70th Road in Kew Gardens Hills, in the middle of a monochrome block of identical, low-slung, attached brick houses. But to Simon, his childhood comes back to him in nice bright colours, teeming with ballplayers, hoodlums â€“ â€œI was a wannabe gang memberâ€ â€“ street-corner doo-wop groups, satin summers and clear winter nights. â€œI got real infatuated with lights,â€ he says. â€œI was lying in bed and they were building new houses in the lots across the street. Snow fell at night. The workmen built a bonfire. The light from the bonfire magnified by snow, the way it moved across the ceiling â€“ I loved it. An orange flickering thing.â€
It was Art Garfunkel who long ago pointed out to Simon that, even in boyhood, Simon had an unusual interest in people who liked to do the things Simon liked to do but had different ways of doing them. In those days, Simon would put his baseball glove over the handles of his Schwinn bicycle with the baseball cards in the wheel spokes â€“ â€œto sound like a motorâ€ â€“ and leave Kew Gardens Hills in search of pickup games in far-flung Italian and Irish neighbourhoods. Unknown schoolyards were exotic places to Simon, and he enjoyed the company of strangers. â€œArtie used to say, â€˜You were the kid who knew more kids in different neighbourhoods,â€™â€ says Simon. â€œI was a ballplayer. Iâ€™d go on my bike, and Iâ€™d hustle kids in stickball.â€ Simon has essentially approached his entire creative life as a series of bike trips, riding in and out of different musical neighbourhoods, responding to something new.
As a boy, Simon often crooned to himself in the bathroom with the lights off, enjoying the reverb of the tiles â€“ hence, â€œHello darkness, my old friend.â€ But he was singing alone in his bedroom with the baseball pennants on the wall when the door opened, and there was Lou Simon telling him what a nice voice he had. Nobody had ever said that to him before. â€œHe was in a tuxedo, going out the door to a club date,â€ Simon recalls. â€œMy father was a Yankee fan. I used to listen to games with my father. He was a nice guy. Fun. Funny. Smart. He didnâ€™t play with me as much as I played with my kids. He was at work until late at night.â€ Sometimes, at two in the morning, when Lou Simon at last turned on to 70th Road, he couldnâ€™t tell which driveway was his and pulled his car into the wrong one. â€œIt really frustrated him,â€ says Simon. â€œWe had to be quiet in the morning. I used to watch him shave. He used to say, â€˜I really donâ€™t feel like working tonight,â€™ a feeling I came to understand.â€
It was baseball that introduced Simon to rock & roll. He was the sort of Yankee fan who kept a scorebook and tore up Red Sox cards as a matter of principle. One day, as he was listening to his radio, waiting for the broadcast of the game to begin, the DJ said, â€œI have a new record. Itâ€™s the worst thing Iâ€™ve ever heard. If this is a hit, Iâ€™ll eat my hat.â€ The song was â€˜Gee,â€™ a doo-wop number by the Crows. Simon was transfixed. â€œThis is the first thing this guyâ€™s played that I like!â€ he thought.
Simon was the kind of categorical listener who knew precisely what he liked, and how much he liked it. His first favourite song was a doo-wop hit, â€˜Sincerelyâ€™ by Harvey and the Moonglows. His two â€œunattainable pinnaclesâ€ remain Elvis Presleyâ€™s song â€˜Mystery Trainâ€™ and the Bo Diddley beat. The beacon in the distance he might reach someday is the great Iowa harmony singers Don and Phil Everly. â€œI wasnâ€™t exposed to poetry at all as a boy,â€ Simon says. â€œBut the music I heard conjured up a kind of poetry. Seemed very mysterious to me. A kind of delightful mysterious. I thought the name Elvis Presley was one of the weirdest names I ever heard.â€ As he sorted through it all, trying to find his own voice, he realised he could never sound raunchy and Southern like Presley, so he went the other way, following softer examples like Sam Cooke, Clyde McPhatter, and the Fleetwoods.
All the sounds Simon liked as a boy remain fresh in him today, and he continues to draw from them. The new albumâ€™s title song, â€˜So Beautiful or So What,â€™ features what he says is â€œone of my favourite Bo Diddley rhythms.â€ (It also references the Miles Davis tune â€˜So What.â€™) In his earlier songs, Simon is prone to naming his favourite doo-wop groups and their hits. His work references such a broad geography of music that he is sometimes accused of being someone, as he puts it, who â€œflits around from culture to culture,â€ but to him, when he encounters something new that he likes, an inevitable part of the appeal is that it doesnâ€™t really seem new at all. In 1985, when Simon travelled to South Africa and began to work with Ladysmith Black Mambazo, their harmonies so closely resembled the doo-wop of his childhood that he found their sound to be â€œa very familiar thing.â€
Simon and Garfunkel met during a grade-school production of â€˜Alice in Wonderland.â€™ Simon played the White Rabbit and Garfunkel the Cheshire Cat. (A musicologist will someday be tempted to make something of this; he shouldnâ€™t.) Soon the two boys were hanging out in their basements, imitating the Everly Brothers. At a time when most people didnâ€™t think of singing pop songs as a serious musical endeavour, Garfunkel shared Simonâ€™s belief that in rock & roll there were vast creative possibilities for two teenagers who liked to mesh their voices. Even at that point, both boys had a professional sense of commitment to music: They would do whatever it took. â€œI missed baseball practice once for a talent show,â€ says Simon. â€œThe baseball coach, he didnâ€™t like it. He told me, â€˜Paul, you better make up your mind if you want to play baseball or you want to sing. You gotta get serious, Paul.â€™â€
At 16, using the stage name Tom and Jerry, the two had the first of their many hits, a teenage come-hither called â€˜Hey, Schoolgirl.â€™ As Simon and Garfunkel, it took them longer. While Garfunkel pursued mathematics at Columbia, Simon studied English at Queens College and worked jobs in the music industry. One of his employers was Amy Records, a small company on Broadway near the Brill Building. â€œAfter school, Iâ€™d come into town and listen to masters people sent in,â€ Simon says. â€œI knew where that record company was â€“ the bottom. They got nothing choice. I didnâ€™t accept anything.â€ Another year, Simon was hired by the song publisher E.B. Marks and charged with peddling weary chestnuts from the Marks catalogue like â€˜The Peanut Vendorâ€™ to record companies. â€œI couldnâ€™t sell one song,â€ says Simon. â€œIt was rock & rollâ€™s time. I felt bad, I couldnâ€™t get anything sold, and so Iâ€™d write a song and let them publish it.â€
Each time he met with a record company, Simon had to write up a report. One day, the man who owned E.B. Marks called him in and asked, â€œWho wrote this report?â€ Simon answered that he had. The man said, â€œNo, you didnâ€™t.â€ Simon said, â€œYes, I did.â€ The man insisted, â€œNo, you didnâ€™t. Itâ€™s written too well.â€ Simon lost his temper. â€œI majored in English lit,â€ he told the man. â€œAnd fuck you, I quit.â€ From then on, he decided, he would publish every one of his songs himself. He took the next one to Columbia Records and met with the producer Tom Wilson. â€œIâ€™d like to use that song with this group the Pilgrims,â€ Wilson told him. Simon said, â€œI sing it with a friend. Can we sing it for you?â€ Wilson agreed. â€œSo,â€ says Simon, â€œArtie and I go up there and sing â€˜The Sound of Silence.â€™ We sang it, and to our surprise, they signed us.â€
That was in 1964. Columbia put out the album Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. At first, it went nowhere. â€œBy that time,â€ Simon says, â€œthe Beatles already existed, the Stones already existed, Dylan already existed. There seemed to be no place to fit in. You couldnâ€™t get up to the feeding trough. They had covered the landscape. But they didnâ€™t have what we had: New York doo-wop.â€
Wilson went back into the studio, and without telling Simon or Garfunkel, he added rock instrumentation to â€˜The Sound of Silenceâ€™ and re-released it. So it was that one Saturday night in 1966, the two best friends were sitting in Simonâ€™s car, parked on a quiet corner in Kew Gardens Hills. They had no gigs, no dates, nowhere to go and nothing to do. The car radio was switched on, and as they talked, the DJ was concluding the weekly countdown of the nationâ€™s top hits. At last, he reached Number One. â€œHello darkness, my old friend,â€ it began.
Garfunkel spoke first. â€œNow those guys,â€ he said, â€œmust be having a big life!â€
Simon still loves the memory. â€œArtie!â€ he says. â€œHe was funny. I guess people like the idea that we canâ€™t stand each other. That we donâ€™t get along. We were best friends. Nobody made me laugh like Artie.â€
Simon and Garfunkel was, Simon says, â€œan incredible adventure. Just to travel, get on a plane, go to a town Iâ€™d never been to. At the beginning, we were thrilled to stay in a Holiday Inn: â€˜Oh, great! They have a vibrating bed!â€™ The kids would invite us to their parties. We were only a couple of years older than they were. Artie sometimes hitchhiked from one gig to another.â€
With their five albums in six years, Simon and Garfunkel created among the most melodic, beautifully interwoven harmonies in American musical history. In the process they became something like musical brothers. â€œWe really have a unique blend of voices,â€ says Simon. â€œIt pulls you back, that blend.â€ But as rewarding as the collaboration was, it also pushed them apart. Both were willful and sharp-witted, bright and sensitive. â€œIâ€™ve had terrible fights with Artie about things,â€ Simon says. â€œSometimes artistic things. But Artie doesnâ€™t write. We didnâ€™t really fight until â€˜Bridge Over Troubled Water.â€™ That had a lot to do with Artie making a movie at the same time.â€
The movie was Catch-22, directed by Mike Nichols, who had commissioned â€˜Mrs. Robinsonâ€™ for The Graduate. Since Simon wrote all the songs, it was understandable that Garfunkel might want a little artistic independence â€“ might wish to create a role for himself rather than simply interpreting his shared part. But while Garfunkel was down in Sonora, Mexico, waiting and waiting for Nichols to film his scenes, Simon was working unassisted on their next album and feeling abandoned. He set down one of his last songs for Simon and Garfunkel, â€˜The Only Living Boy in New York,â€™ in which â€œTomâ€ flies down to Mexico, leaving the singer with â€œnothing to do today but smile.â€ Something else Simon was working on while Garfunkel was in Mexico was a soaring hymn he still feels Garfunkelâ€™s voice alone is â€œparticularly suited to.â€ After the record came out, Garfunkel would go onstage and perform â€˜Bridge Over Troubled Water,â€™ and as he did, Simon would stand in the wings, anticipating the torrents of -applause to follow and thinking, â€œThatâ€™s my song, man.â€
Soon the friends went their separate ways. â€œSimon and Garfunkel is a minefield,â€ Simon says now. â€œItâ€™s very hard to be in a duo. I was very liberated by the breakup of Simon and Garfunkel.â€
Four decades later, â€˜Bridge Over Troubled Waterâ€™ has been played on the radio more than 7 million times. In all, songs written by Simon have been broadcast over 100 million times. Three of his 16 albums â€“ Bridge Over Troubled Water, Still Crazy After All These Years and Graceland â€“ have won the Grammy for Best Album. Simon has received a sufficient number of lifetime-achievement awards, from the likes of the Kennedy Center and the Library of Congress, that there is no one who would suggest he acted imprudently when he left Brooklyn Law School after a â€œwasted yearâ€ in 1963, and set off hitchhiking, looking for America with only a guitar and a suitcase.
Still, there is a stigma about Simon that might be summarised as the belief in some critical corners that he hasnâ€™t suffered enough. The complaint seems to be that Simon is too literate, too earnest, too neurotic â€“ in short, too much like a music critic. â€œHe has always been the smart, bourgeois, fussy wimp who makes some self-styled rockers want to kick sand in his face,â€ is how Jon Pareles once described him in The New York Times. When Simon, searching for inspiration, travelled to apartheid-era South Africa in 1985 to record with local black musicians, American critics called him a cultural opportunist. And when he spent the early 1990s working on his Broadway musical, The Capeman, they portrayed him as an interloping egomaniac.
Simon experiences the world in such a full and detailed way, itâ€™s easy to imagine the vivid impressions he must have accumulated across more than 50 years at the centre of American popular music. But though he applauds Stephen Sondheim for exacting â€œdeliciousâ€ revenge in his recent memoir, Finishing the Hat, donâ€™t expect any such revelations from Simon. These days he seems like a novelist in late autumn, working as hard as ever, but taking contented pleasure in family, friends and the daily newspaper. He has forsaken his penthouse duplex overlooking Central Park for the suburbs, where life as the only living boy in New Canaan seems to suit him. He now writes most of his songs in the car, a black SUV he selected for its acoustics. He sings to himself as he ferries his three kids around, and then, when he hits on something good, he remembers it until he gets home. â€œI donâ€™t talk that much about my life, my past,â€ he tells me, sitting in his office in midtown Manhattan. Hearing him say those last two words in his familiar, gently longing outer-borough baritone brings to mind the weary man in Simonâ€™s song â€˜Gone at Last,â€™ who takes harbour at a truck stop on a snowy night for some â€œthinking about my past.â€
If youâ€™ve spent your life listening to Simon sing about scarred, resilient people grappling with lifeâ€™s disappointments, thereâ€™s something affirming about how unchanged his voice sounds as he approaches his 70th birthday. You have only to listen to the precise way he enunciates his suffixes, the many pauses he favours in conversation, to grasp that clarity and emotional precision are crucial to him. His voice is often faulted for its limitations of size, but it has the advantage of New York character. In the same way the cityâ€™s Upper West Side can feel like a Woody Allen movie in real time, itâ€™s easy to hear every word spoken by New Yorkers as lyrics from a Paul Simon song: your barber when he tells you, â€œThat seems to be OK,â€ or the woman in line getting coffee, rearranging her position on â€œthis guy I had a little bit of a thing with.â€
But Simon believes that his voice is part of what makes people hard on him. â€œOne of my deficiencies is my voice sounds sincere,â€ he says. â€œIâ€™ve tried to sound ironic. I donâ€™t. I canâ€™t. Dylan, everything he sings has two meanings. Heâ€™s telling you the truth and making fun of you at the same time. I sound sincere every time. Rock & roll has a lot to do with image. If thatâ€™s not your strength, people find fault with the work.â€
In particular, Simon has spent his professional life being condemned for not being Dylan. â€œThereâ€™s always some kind of comparison between us,â€ he says. â€œI usually come in second. I donâ€™t like coming in second. In the very, very beginning, when we were first signed to Columbia, I really admired Dylanâ€™s work. â€˜The Sound of Silenceâ€™ wouldnâ€™t have been written if it werenâ€™t for Dylan. But I left that feeling around The Graduate and â€˜Mrs. Robinson.â€™ They werenâ€™t folky anymore.â€
Simonâ€™s office is in the Brill Building on Broadway. In the late 1950s and early 1960s, when Simon was coming into Manhattan by subway from Queens to hustle songs, the Brill Building was for popular songwriters what Silicon Valley is for computer programmers today. There are art deco ceiling lamps, Italian chairs, plants, an Asian screen, a desk that doesnâ€™t look as though it has seen much service and a piano that seems more experienced. The books that Simon has on hand include biographies of Bruce Springsteen and Sylvia Plath stacked with a collection of John Berrymanâ€™s poetry. Simon agrees with his friend, the poet Billy Collins, that song lyrics are not poems. â€œI donâ€™t like the honorific lifting up of something else to poetry,â€ Collins says. â€œPoetry in motion and so on. I hold rock lyrics to their own standard. â€˜Whiter Shade of Pale,â€™ you have no idea what that means, itâ€™s just a great song.â€ But Paul McCartney disagrees. â€œHeâ€™s a poet!â€ McCartney says of Simon. â€œThe same rules of poetry apply to a songwriter. Economy, phrase, rhythm. Allen Ginsberg always wanted you to say, â€˜Is this a song or a poem?â€™ If it was a song, heâ€™d leave you alone. If it was a poem, heâ€™d knock it to pieces.â€
For all of his celebrity, when Simon goes shopping for groceries, he is still capable of convincing himself that nobody notices him as he walks the aisles. Then, after he makes his purchases, he feels flustered to find people approaching him. â€œPaul McCartney is always aware that somebodyâ€™s watching him,â€ Simon says. â€œI never think anybodyâ€™s watching me. Iâ€™m naive.â€ Like many diffident writers who bring intimate themes from their own life into their work, there seems to be a necessary disconnect in Simon that wants always to consider the flashes of self-portrait that are layered into his songs as lyrics rather than life. â€œI donâ€™t usually write autobiographically anymore,â€ he says. But people approach Simon in supermarket checkout lines partly because he has written so well about that most enduringly seductive subject, doomed romances. Among Simon and Garfunkelâ€™s more popular songs are â€˜Kathyâ€™s Songâ€™ and â€˜America,â€™ which feature Simonâ€™s former girlfriend, Kathy Chitty. â€œBefore I knew him, I knew Kathy,â€ says Simonâ€™s friend, Saturday Night Live producer Lorne Michaels, voicing an impression shared by many fans. Simon wrote the last verse of â€˜Bridge Over Troubled Waterâ€™ â€“ which begins â€œSail on, silvergirlâ€ â€“ after his first wife, Peggy Harper, noticed her first grey hairs. The medley of love-damaged songs he wrote with his second wife, the actress Carrie Fisher, in mind, includes â€˜Hearts and Bones,â€™ â€˜Allergiesâ€™ and â€˜She Moves On,â€™ in which Simon describes a man â€œabandoned, forsaken in her cold coffee eyes.â€
All this, of course, can be hard on the mortals who inspired the timeless songs. When discussing the interplay of personal history and imagination, Simonâ€™s desire â€œnot to hurt anybodyâ€ always trumps disclosure. When I ask Simon about his song â€˜I Do It for Your Love,â€™ he says, â€œThatâ€™s about my first wife, Peggy. I met Peggyâ€¦ better not to go into that!â€ Harper is a reserved woman from a hamlet in the east Tennessee hills. Carrie Fisher, on the other hand, is a former Hollywood princess who has seemed to spend her life getting into everything. She has written that Simon is a â€œmagic personâ€ and described herself as a â€œbitch,â€ explaining that Simon â€œhad to put up with a lotâ€ during their dozen years together. Simonâ€™s response? â€œI donâ€™t want to talk about Carrie,â€ he says. â€œI donâ€™t mean I dislike her. I donâ€™t dislike Carrie Fisher. I just donâ€™t want to get into it. Sheâ€™s a writer. Sheâ€™s entitled to her life and to write about it as she wishes.â€
It hasnâ€™t escaped Simonâ€™s notice that the more he kept his personal life to himself, the better life got. â€œAt a certain point,â€ he says, â€œyou begin to realise about your life and your private affairs that itâ€™s inappropriate that it should be entertainment for somebody else. Thereâ€™s no requirement that I tell how I hurt and how I feel. Itâ€™s a mistake you make early on. I see Eminem out there talking about his family, his kids, and I think 10 or 15 years from now heâ€™ll regret it.â€ Simon refuses to discuss his children, including his eldest son, Harper, who has struggled to define himself as a musician since he toured with his dad on Graceland at age 14. â€œItâ€™s a very high bar that he set,â€ Harper has said. â€œIf you canâ€™t be up at that level, why bother, you know?â€
Near the entrance to Simonâ€™s office, there are several framed pictures of baseball players, among them Jackie Robinson, the Negro Leagues star Buck Oâ€™Neil, Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio and a fleet of other New York Yankees. â€œI like baseball,â€ he says. â€œProbably my favourite thing. When it comes to the end of life, Iâ€™ll say it was baseball and music. Thatâ€™ll be it.â€ What Simon savours most about the sport is line drives. â€œThat feeling of the ball hitting the bat so perfectly, you donâ€™t feel it,â€ he says. â€œItâ€™s like writing a great line. You donâ€™t even feel it. You think, Ahhh! Itâ€™s perfectly concise. Anybody who has not experienced it canâ€™t understand.â€ His favourite player was Mantle, who, when he met Simon, wanted to know why, if that was the case, DiMaggio was the one Simon had immortalised in song. Simon explained about syllables, how it helps when they glide along for a while. When Simon encountered DiMaggio in an Italian restaurant, the Yankee Clipper also had questions: â€œWhat does that mean â€“ Where have you gone?â€ He let Simon know he hadnâ€™t gone anywhere. He was doing ads for Mr. Coffee. Simon told DiMaggio about the potency of vanishing heroes. As for the line itself, how it came to him at age 26, all Simon has ever been able to say is, â€œI donâ€™t know where it came from, but all of a sudden it was there.â€
Leaning against a wall in the near corner of the office, not far from the baseball display, is a double bass. The instrument is so large that once you notice it, the bass seems to loom over the room. Simon says it belonged to his father, who remains a strong presence for him. The New York Times once reported that the two had a â€œfamously tortured relationship.â€ This was said especially to be true after Simon became celebrated for making a kind of music that Lou Simon considered trivial. Not true, Simon says with indignation. â€œI imagine he was amazed and kind of happy for me,â€ he says. â€œI had a very good relationship with my mother and father. Complicated with my father, but certainly loving. I think it was fame. For my mother it was pure joy. For my father â€“ he never said this â€“ there came a point where enough was enough. The only thing I can remember â€“ and my father is the person who most influenced my thinking and my life â€“ he said, â€˜Of course Iâ€™m very happy for you. I canâ€™t argue with your success. But is that really what you want to be, a rock star?â€™ I said, â€˜Yeah! Why not? What should I be? What am I supposed to be?â€™ He said, â€˜A teacher.â€™â€
In the late Seventies, Lou Simon abruptly put down his bass, went back to school at New York University, received a doctorate in linguistics, and became a professor of education at City College. â€œItâ€™s complicated,â€ says Simon. â€œHereâ€™s a guy, a musician all his life. In his fifties, he leaves and goes and gets his PhD Extraordinary. Heâ€™s a star in his own right, but heâ€™s also the father of Paul Simon. For him, it was a mix.â€ Simon pauses. â€œItâ€™s very hard to know what your father is thinking,â€ he says. â€œI was working on St Lucia when he died. His health had been failing. He took a nap and he died.â€
Scattered throughout Simonâ€™s office are photos of Artie, Dion, Al Gore, Lorne Michaels, Philip Glass, Leonard Bernstein, the Brazilian singer Milton Nascimento, the Smothers Brothers, Kate Smith, the wife and kids. A handsome walnut cabinet houses a Kodachrome-era hi-fi. â€œThis stuff is old,â€ Simon says about the stereo. â€œIâ€™m not a technophile.â€ Along the walls there is a weekend watercolour portrait of Simon painted by his mother, the framed string arrangement Simon commissioned for â€˜Bridge Over Troubled Waterâ€™ that the composer hastily mistitled â€˜Like a Pitcher of Waterâ€™ and a letter from George Gershwin, in which he pitches himself to one AM Wattenberg: â€œOur Astaire picture, Shall We Dance, looks first-rate.â€
Simon smiles. â€œSongwriter insecurity,â€ he says. â€œI never met a secure writer. Theyâ€™re all competitive, and theyâ€™re all paying attention to what people say about them, which is what makes people crazy.â€ Is this true of him? â€œI donâ€™t think of myself as insecure in the world,â€ he replies quietly. I say that he seems like a self-confident person who prefers the periphery. â€œPeriphery is true,â€ he says. I mention the â€œimmobilisingâ€ depression he once described after the failures of his film and album One-Trick Pony, and the simultaneous disintegration of his relationship with Carrie Fisher. â€œThereâ€™ve been times Iâ€™ve been depressed,â€ he says even more quietly. â€œNot to say there havenâ€™t been times of self-doubt. I wouldnâ€™t say I was happy-go-lucky.â€
You donâ€™t have to recall the cover photograph of Simonâ€™s brilliant self-titled 1972 debut solo album, in which his face is half-obscured by a thick frame of parka fur, to sense that he is the kind of man who can be a little hard on himself. But if Simon has seemed furtive across his long career, itâ€™s because he isnâ€™t really nonchalant about anything. The singer-songwriter Randy Newman recalls playing catcher in a wiffle-ball game on Long Island when Simon came to bat. â€œI could hear him talking to himself,â€ recalls Newman, who has known Simon casually for years. â€œReally competitive. Unusually competitive. He wants to win at stuff.â€ As Simon himself often stresses, his music is the best of him â€“ â€œas opposed to when Iâ€™m being a real asshole and then later regretting it. Everybody famous is an asshole at times, and the only thing interesting about it is the excuse for why youâ€™re such an asshole.â€
Anyone who knows Simonâ€™s best songs realises how musically invested he is in that question of why flawed men and women are the way they are. Vulnerability is his great subject. Like all the great artists, heâ€™s more interested in process than resolution, in the smallest subtleties of feeling. His characters are downcast, unguarded people trying to keep up their hopes (â€œI do believe, if I hadnâ€™t met you, I might still be sinking fastâ€) and striving to connect (â€œYou donâ€™t feel you could love me, but I feel you couldâ€). To those who know him, like Billy Collins, Simon is â€œa good example of the examined lifeâ€ â€“ something I come to appreciate at the studio early one evening, when Simon tells me how a long, disorienting interval in his life became a single perfect line in a song.
It was a decade ago, and Simon was suddenly overcome with self-loathing. â€œI really attacked myself,â€ he recalls. â€œIt was a brutal attack. I didnâ€™t tell anybody. It was like a voice inside me was really attacking me.â€ When he tried to defend himself against the assault from within, the voice wouldnâ€™t let him. â€œYou got it wrong,â€ it told him. â€œThis isnâ€™t a trial. Itâ€™s a sentencing. Weâ€™re not interested in how good you talk. Thatâ€™s just a cover-up.â€
At the time, Simon was having trouble with pain in both hands and he worried about his future ability to play an instrument. He visited a doctor, and after the physical examination, Simon told him about the voice that made him feel that everything he did was wrong. The doctor asked Simon if he was game for something unconventional. Sure, said Simon. The doctor knew a former psychiatrist, a man of great skill, who had closed his practice and gone to work for a church in Baltimore. Simon telephoned the man. â€œI told him the whole thing about my attack on my ego,â€ he says. In response, the man in Baltimore said that encountering an extraordinarily harsh inner voice is not an uncommon experience for writers. The man asked Simon to choose a voice he thought of as comic â€“ perhaps Bugs Bunnyâ€™s voice â€“ and told him to try to hear the harsh voice as Bugs. Then, the man said, Simon should take the now-defused voice and put it under his shoe.
â€œI understood his point,â€ Simon says. â€œYouâ€™re fooled because itâ€™s your inner voice. Itâ€™s not uncommon for people to get down on themselves and hit all their own wounded spots. You can really hurt yourself. This was a way of saying donâ€™t pay attention to yourself. It was good advice.â€ The idea eventually showed up on the album Surprise, in â€˜Sure Donâ€™t Feel Like Love,â€™ when Simon sings, â€œWhoâ€™s that conscience sticking on the sole of my shoe?â€
During another conversation at the rehearsal studio, Simon tells me about a book, A Giacometti Portrait, heâ€™d read years ago that was still strikingly vivid for him. The book is writer James Lordâ€™s account of being painted by his friend, the Swiss artist Alberto Giacometti. â€œEvery day, Giacometti finished the portrait and said it was awful,â€ Simon recounts enthusiastically. â€œThe degree to which he beats himself up is hilarious. I can be pretty rough on myself. But him â€“ he really beat himself up. Heâ€™d get better and better and then say, â€˜This is just unacceptable! One thing the world will be spared is this crap, this kind of mediocrity out of me, talentless nothing that I am.â€™ Heâ€™d do this over and over until Lord told him, â€˜Donâ€™t touch it, youâ€™ve got it now.â€™ But Giacometti took it apart and redid it and did it better. That constant editing and self-criticism â€“ I liked it.â€
Other artists are often surprised by the lengths to which Simon will go to â€œdestroy everything with great bravery,â€ as Giacometti put it. A few years ago, Simon agreed to sing one of his forlorn masterpieces, â€˜I Do It for Your Love,â€™ on an album of covers the jazz pianist Herbie Hancock was making. But as the two musicians consulted about the song, Simon surprised Hancock by suggesting that they significantly rework the tune, reducing its complex structure to a single chord and switching it to a minor key. â€œThe recording we did is a completely different idea of the song from the one he wrote,â€ Hancock marvels. Simonâ€™s musical â€œcuriosityâ€ reminded Hancock of his old boss, Miles Davis. â€œMiles and Paul arenâ€™t in boxes,â€ he says. â€œA couple of geniuses with heads full of ideas.â€
With Simon, it always seems to come back around to where it all comes from, how everything put together gets put together. During a recent public conversation with Billy Collins at a college in Florida, Simon told the audience about â€˜Love and Hard Times,â€™ one of the new songs on So Beautiful or So What, and he spoke in such detail about his process that he brought to mind for Collins â€œa Ferrari mechanic taking the engine apart. He had a very clear sense how his music is constructed. The old question: Does the music or the lyric come first? For him, clearly the beat comes first. Heâ€™s not just Rhyminâ€™ Simon, heâ€™s Rhythmic Simon. He picked up his guitar and played â€˜Mystery Trainâ€™ and said, â€˜Forty per cent of my music is based on that.â€™ More than most writers, heâ€™s willing to admit his music is an assemblage of different influences.â€
By reimagining existing forms of music and making surprising linkages across a vast palette of sound patterns old and new, Simon has always been ahead of his time. In 1965, at ThÃ©Ã¢tre de lâ€™Est Parisien, he heard the Peruvian band Los Incas using charangos and pan flutes to play the Andean folk song â€˜El Condor Pasa,â€™ which he subsequently adapted into the Simon and Garfunkel song â€˜If I Could.â€™ â€œIâ€™d never heard those instruments,â€ he says. â€œI loved it. Maybe I have the capacity to have my emotions touched by sounds and rhythms of different cultures as well as the first stuff I heard on the radio in adolescence, when most peopleâ€™s emotions are touched.â€
In 1971, for his first solo album, Simon returned to Paris and recorded a broken-shoed shimmy called â€˜Hoboâ€™s Bluesâ€™ with the legendary jazz violinist StÃ©phane Grappelli. That same year, he visited Jamaica. He had heard Jimmy Cliffâ€™s ska song â€˜Vietnam,â€™ and it inspired a song about a smaller family tragedy from Simon. â€œIf you really want something,â€ he says, â€œyou gotta go to where they play it.â€ When he got to Kingston, he met up with members of Cliffâ€™s band, Toots and the Maytals. â€œI showed them my song and said, â€˜I want to do a ska version.â€™ They said, â€˜We donâ€™t do ska anymore.â€™ I said, â€˜What do you do?â€™ They said, â€˜We play reggae.â€™ I said, â€˜Whatâ€™s that sound like?â€™ They played it. I said, â€˜Letâ€™s do it!â€™â€ The title of Simonâ€™s song was itself a sly allusion to provenance. On a menu at a restaurant in Chinatown, he saw a chicken and egg dish called â€˜Mother and Child Reunion.â€™ The song, as Simon puts it, â€œbecame the first reggae hit by a non-Jamaican white guy outside Jamaica.â€
By that time, Simonâ€™s ambitions were growing beyond the diverse songs he was writing for his first three solo albums. In 1977, Woody Allen cast him in Annie Hall, as the music producer for whom Annie leaves Alvy Singer. â€œAllenâ€™s instructions were really simple,â€ recalls Simon. â€œCome in, say anything you want, and invite her to a party. Be sure you say itâ€™s gonna be â€˜very mellow.â€™ When he first wrote the part, it was all wrong. I said, â€˜Heâ€™s not gonna be a stupid guy!â€™ Woodyâ€™s not a fan of rock & roll, as everybody knows. But he let me pick everything â€“ the coke spoon dangling around my neck, the stuff I said about Jack and Anjelica coming to my party.â€
On the set, Simon encountered the actress Shelley Duvall, who eventually came to live with him in New York. Across the hall was the apartment of Lorne Michaels, the pal in whom Simon used to confide when the time came to slip out the back or make a new plan. One day, Simon stopped by for such a conversation about Duvall. â€œIt wasnâ€™t a good match, and he kind of recognised that,â€ says Michaels. But Simon cared for Duvall and didnâ€™t want to be unkind. â€œYou have to be really direct,â€ was Michaelsâ€™ counsel. â€œYou have to say, â€˜Iâ€™m not in love with you.â€™ Unless youâ€™re direct, she wonâ€™t hear it.â€
A day later Michaels ran into Duvall. â€œI guess you talked to Paul,â€ she said. Michaels said that he had, and asked her what had happened. â€œWell,â€ she said, â€œhe said, â€˜Iâ€™m not in love with you. I care about you. Iâ€™ll help you find an apartment. But itâ€™s over.â€™â€ Michaels was sympathetic. â€œShelley, that had to be hard,â€ he said. â€œHow do you feel?â€ Duvall looked at him and shrugged. â€œHeâ€™s in one of his moods,â€ she said.
In 1980, Simon wrote, composed the soundtrack for and starred in the film One-Trick Pony. â€œI had fun,â€ Simon says, â€œbut it wasnâ€™t a very good piece of work.â€ Few people were passionate about his next album, Hearts and Bones. Feeling musically bereft, Simon happened to hear a tape of South African township jive, and he liked it so well that he headed for Johannesburg. The bass player Bakithi Kumalo was working in a garage when a call came through that the American who wrote â€˜Homeward Boundâ€™ wanted Kumalo to come record with him. â€œI had no idea what he was looking for,â€ says Kumalo, who has been Simonâ€™s bassist ever since. â€œBut he came and just fell in love with the music and that was good for everyone. It was fresh for us and fresh for Americans, too. Deep! And for me, as a South African, to hear music in English and then how he put everything together â€“ it was unbelievable.â€
Simon was criticised by some for plundering African music, but to many musicians, his methods are unusual only for how conspicuously he acknowledges his artistic debts. (â€œI never invented anything,â€ he says.) â€œWhatâ€™s the expression?â€ asks Paul McCartney. â€œA good artist borrows, a great artist steals? Fair enough! Weâ€™re all heavily influenced. When I heard Graceland, I had always loved African things. Iâ€™d gone to Lagos to do Band on the Run. I had a similar idea in mind â€“ to be influenced. Everybody does it in all forms of art â€“ uses their influences as a turn-on. The difference with Paul is he does it very well. Graceland was dangerous territory, and he more than pulled it off.â€
Back in New York in 1987, at the Greenwich Village club Sounds of Brazil, Simon fell into a conversation with Dizzy Gillespie and the Puerto Rican jazz musician Eddie Palmieri. Together they told him, â€œYou canâ€™t just make an African album and leave it at that. Now youâ€™re on the trail!â€ Then they gave him an impromptu history of the way West African drumming had travelled through Brazil and on up to Cuba. Over the course of a year, Simon made visits to several Brazilian cities with his longtime producer, Phil Ramone. In Salvador, they were passing through Pillory Square in an old, impoverished section of the city when they heard the sound of drums. â€œPaulâ€™s curious,â€ recalls Ramone. â€œWe see 20 drummers on a street. Paul gets them to agree to record on an old 8-track. I hot-wired it through a manhole cover in a schoolyard.â€ By the end of the trip, Simon was so excited by what he had collected that he never followed through on a planned trip to Cuba. Instead, he wrote The Rhythm of the Saints.
Other influences emerged closer to home. One day in the late Sixties, while Simon was out for a walk in Central Park, a young Puerto Rican man tripping on acid approached him and said, â€œYouâ€™re Paul Simon!â€ The manâ€™s name was Carlos Ortiz. â€œHe was an interesting guy,â€ Simon recalls. â€œI was in the same general state. It was the day of the Puerto Rican Day parade. He sort of linked up with me wandering through the park.â€ The two stayed in touch, and one day Ortiz gave Simon a tour of his South Bronx neighbourhood. â€œWe canâ€™t go down that block,â€ he would say, explaining to Simon all about the local gangs.
That day stayed with Simon. After Rhythm of the Saints, he dedicated five full years to working with the playwright Derek Walcott, melding doo-wop harmonies, gospel music and Latin rhythms to the New York story of a Puerto Rican gang member who commits a murder and spends the rest of his life journeying toward deliverance. The Capeman was the Spider-Man of its day. New York newspapers breathlessly reported the musicalâ€™s production troubles and spiralling costs. After the opening, the Times panned it twice, dismissing it as â€œsadly ineptâ€ and a â€œhopelessly confused drone.â€ It was a â€œbig flop,â€ says Simon. â€œThat felt personal, and your feelings get hurt. There was real glee. Youâ€™re always surprised that a lot of people dislike you. You think, â€˜Iâ€™m a good guy!â€™ Turns out a lotta people donâ€™t agree.â€
A streamlined revival of The Capeman was staged last year by the Public Theater in Central Park. Some of what was removed from the original were lines written by Walcott. â€œWe had a great collaboration for several years, then things sort of deteriorated,â€ Walcott says. â€œThis is a heavy thing for me. A lot of it is extremely painful. Paul justifies his conduct as â€˜Art is number one.â€™ I think friendship is more important than art.â€ This time the production received a flattering notice from the Times, which called it â€œan organic part of a New York tradition of tale-telling.â€
Simon says often that he no longer writes hits, he writes albums. As he works, he sometimes drops in on other musicians and tries out his new songs on them â€“ an experience that Neil Diamond, for one, says both â€œinspiresâ€ and â€œsometimes intimidatesâ€ him to the point where â€œmore than once, Iâ€™ve thought I should find a different kind of work.â€
When Simon wants to talk about his craft, the person he goes to see is Philip Glass. The two have been close friends for 30 years, ever since Simon asked Glass to write a string coda for â€˜The Late Great Johnny Ace,â€™ his elegy to John Lennon and John F Kennedy. Glass considers Simon â€œthe most important songwriter of his generation,â€ but he knows that Simon isnâ€™t always so sure. Early in their friendship, the two were talking when Simon suddenly expressed his envy of the kind of â€œserious musicâ€ Glass composes. â€œIâ€™m just a songwriter,â€ Simon said. â€œNobodyâ€™s gonna remember who I was.â€ Glass was stunned. â€œYouâ€™re crazy!â€ he told Simon. â€œYouâ€™re one of the most significant American composers. Your music is classical. It will be heard as long as people listen to music.â€ Simon looked surprised. â€œYou think so?â€ he asked. â€œYes,â€ Glass said, â€œI think so.â€
Early in his career, Simon learned that one of his favourite writers, the poet Philip Larkin, despaired that his muse had deserted him. â€œThat had a big effect on me,â€ Simon recalls. â€œIt made me scared that could happen to me.â€ It never has. As a successful artist who remains preoccupied with loss, Simon proved it was possible to live a full life making what was once only the music of youth. â€œLot of evidence people do their best work early in this field,â€ says Randy Newman. â€œPaulâ€™s last three records are as good as anything heâ€™s ever done. I hear things in So Beautiful or So What that I like even more than usual. Thereâ€™s always a few things happening â€“ a little counterpoint, a little kick, some tempo changes. Itâ€™s inspiring to hear.â€
One of the new songs on So Beautiful is called â€˜Dazzling Blue.â€™ Simon admits that this one is about his marriage to Edie Brickell. Simonâ€™s many songs about love tend to emphasise the confusions of the condition, but thatâ€™s the story of his old life. â€œIâ€™ve been married three times,â€ he says. â€œThis is a good marriage. About to be 19 years. I didnâ€™t know anything about relationships. I thought it all just worked out, because my parents were happily married. I was distracted by fame and money. I didnâ€™t put time into relationships. I thought, â€˜Itâ€™s all gonna work out.â€™ Then it didnâ€™t.â€
Simon and Brickell met on the set of Saturday Night Live, where she was the weekâ€™s musical guest. â€œThere was definitely a chemistry,â€ recalls Lorne Michaels. Afterward, Simon went to see her perform at the Bottom Line. â€œAll these record people were in back talking to her,â€ he recalls. â€œI felt silly hanging around. I left. I got in my car. I said, â€˜I donâ€™t know why Iâ€™m leaving. I didnâ€™t come to leave.â€™ So I called her on the dressing-room phone and asked if sheâ€™d like to have a drink between shows. We went to a Japanese restaurant in the Village.â€ These days they sing country songs together, like Loretta Lynn and Conway Twittyâ€™s duet â€˜Youâ€™re the Reason Our Kids Are Ugly.â€™
In his office at the Brill Building, Simon switches on the old stereo and plays â€˜Dazzling Blue.â€™ Compared with his past descriptions of benighted love, the relationships that send you â€œfalling, flying or tumbling in turmoil,â€ these lyrics about sun-dappled contentment are restrained. But the sound is a daring, inventive assembly, a shifting series of rhythms, tempos and tones. Simon canâ€™t find the remote for his stereo, so whenever he has a thought during the song, he races from the couch to the amplifier, nimbly evading chairs along the way, to hit pause and explain something. There are many such sprints. â€˜Dazzling Blue!â€™ he enthuses. â€œThatâ€™s Edieâ€™s favourite colour, blue. Thatâ€™s really our story, Edie and I.â€ Simon is wearing a faded blue shirt himself, to go with his jeans. â€œIâ€™m all in blue!â€ he notices. â€œIâ€™m sort of more matchy than I usually am.â€
When the song comes to the line â€œand dream our dreams of dazzling blue,â€ the word â€œdreamâ€ makes Simon call out, â€œItâ€™s like the Everlys!â€ The lyrics go on to -describe cliffs rising above the sea, and Simon, who summers on Long Island, says, â€œThatâ€™s where we live on Montauk.â€ The rest of the year, because Brickell is a Texan who â€œlikes the country,â€ Simon lives in suburban Connecticut. These days, all he wants to do is get some exercise, go to the studio and coach his sonâ€™s baseball team. A few years ago, Simon tried a new sport: cricket. â€œI was the last batsman,â€ he says. â€œI didnâ€™t know you had to wait all day.â€ This was, in the end, no problem, both because when Simon finally stood before the wicket, â€œI hit it over a wall into a churchyard,â€ and because â€œI spent the afternoon talking to Joe Strummer, who I liked immensely. I was so sad he died. Iâ€™d just started to get to know him.â€
That the end might come for him or Garfunkel while they are in one of their periodic disaffections is something Simon thinks about. The two have reconciled repeatedly over the years, only to run aground again and again on their old grievances. In 1981, coming off the failure of One-Trick Pony, Simon agreed to a reunion concert in Central Park that was attended by half a million fans. But a few years later their relationship foundered badly when Simon eliminated Garfunkelâ€™s vocals from a planned reunion album and released it as a solo set. Garfunkel also felt slighted during their induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1990, when he took the podium to thank Simon as â€œthe person who has most enriched my life.â€ Simon responded with a little dig. â€œArthur and I agree about almost nothing,â€ he said. â€œBut itâ€™s true, I have enriched his life quite a bit, now that I think about it.â€ The following year, when Simon performed another concert in Central Park, Garfunkel left town to avoid seeing the crowds from his apartment on Fifth Avenue. â€œIâ€™m not good enough to be invited,â€ he told the Times. â€œMy guess is that it would hurt his sense of stature.â€
In 2001, at his own induction into the Hall of Fame, Simon sought to make amends. â€œI thank Art Garfunkel,â€ he said. â€œI regret the ending of our friendship, and I hope one day before we die weâ€™ll make peace with each other.â€ Eventually they did, going out on tour together in 2003 and reuniting for a moving set at the Hall of Fame concert at Madison Square Garden in 2009. â€œTruth is, I really do enjoy singing with Artie,â€ says Simon. â€œThere was something very emotional we were getting from the audience. The relationship was repaired during that tour. That tour had a big effect on people. People knew we were close friends whoâ€™d had a hurtful rift. We said, â€˜Lifeâ€™s too short.â€™ And the symbolism kind of struck a lot of other people whoâ€™d
had similar struggles in their own lives.â€
When they will sing together again is always the question, and each time Simon hears it he thinks with dismay at the prospect of getting into an argument with Garfunkel and feeling that there he is again right back on 70th Road. â€œThat would be sufficient reason not to work together,â€ he says. But there is always the pull. And now that Garfunkel is suffering from a vocal condition that has kept him from singing for over a year, Simon feels it more strongly than ever. â€œAside from my compassion for him,â€ he says, â€œI also think how terrible it would be if I couldnâ€™t sing with Artie again.â€
Art Garfunkel has warned me that he canâ€™t talk for long because of his injured voice. But as soon as I walk into his large New York apartment, he wants to know what I think of David Bowieâ€™s music, and because I believe that heaven holds a place for his plastic soul, Garfunkel initiates a half-playful debate, arguing that Bowie is more of an artist than a pure musician. Garfunkel wears a white T-shirt and jeans, still the handsome would-be architect about whom Simon once wrote, â€œNever change your point of view/When I run dry, I stop awhile and think of you.â€
We sit in Garfunkelâ€™s third-floor study, which is lined with 1,129 books shelved in the order he has read them. In 1969, to pass the time in Mexico as he waited for his scenes in Catch-22, Garfunkel began the project of reading all the books an educated man ought to know. On the spines of those he especially likes, such as The Oregon Trail and The House of Mirth, Garfunkel places a ladybug sticker. Some of his favorites are by Joyce, George Eliot and Proust, who wrote, â€œEven when one is no longer attached to things, itâ€™s still something to have been attached to them.â€ Number 1,130 is Roderick Nashâ€™s The Wilderness and the American Mind.
Garfunkel is still very connected to Simon. Describing old films being released as part of a new, 40th-anniversary edition of Bridge Over Troubled Water, he talks with great affection about â€œPaul and Artie, these young pishers attending to the job. Weâ€™re absolute workaholics. These guys are bonded to each other and think the world of each other, respect each other, applaud each other. The compatibility of specialness â€“ itâ€™s poetic.â€
As Garfunkel describes the way he and Simon met, it brings to mind how the teenage Paul McCartney had to sell himself to John Lennon. â€œPaul knew when he met me he was secretly pitching for my friendship,â€ Garfunkel says. â€œIâ€™m being an amateur psychologist. But thatâ€™s how life works. He was a turned-on guy, and I was the blonde neighbourhood singer. Girls liked me. I was nice, a motherâ€™s-boy type. Paul made me feel like my sense of humour is hot. We fell in step. Our junior high school was really ratty. You needed your buddy.â€ At home, they took their girlfriends to the opposite ends of the basement, the same place where they became â€œrehearsal freaks,â€ harmonising until dawn.
When he heard So Beautiful, Garfunkel says he was touched by the song â€˜Questions for the Angels,â€™ in which a battered pilgrim searches for his place in a world that seems to have moved past him. â€œI teared up,â€ Garfunkel says. â€œBut heâ€™s not Saint Paul. Heâ€™s a competitive, feisty guy with sharp elbows. What are we gonna do about Paul? A trait like that will help you lose friends.â€
One of the many appealing things about Garfunkel is that all these public years later, he is still who he was â€“ unprotected, without evident pretence. Of his old friend he says, â€œHe looks for real content in everything. Heâ€™s no bullshit. Heâ€™s alive to do real stuff. In a world where smoke and mirrors is good enough, heâ€™s authentic. I get such a charge out of working with him. Heâ€™s such a great musician.â€ I tell Garfunkel that Simon says of his own guitar-picking, â€œI couldnâ€™t play a solo to save my life. Somebody says, â€˜Take it, Paulâ€™ â€“ Iâ€™m not gonna take it anywhere.â€ Garfunkel frowns. â€œHeâ€™s brilliantly sexy as a musician,â€ he says. â€œThe key that made Simon and Garfunkel is his guitar playing. Itâ€™s delicious. Heâ€™s always downplaying it. Itâ€™s a rhythmic way of playing acoustic guitar. I donâ€™t know anybody better. Why do you think â€˜Mrs. Robinsonâ€™ was a hit?â€
â€œYou can not like Paul,â€ he acknowledges. â€œYou can notice, like in everybody, our seamier side. Everybody has their unattractive sides.â€ He removes his glasses and quietly wipes his eyes. After a moment he says, â€œI fought for the Good Record, capital G, capital R. So you fight for what you want, and youâ€™re very different in your differences of opinion, and opinions have a capital O. You have enough differences of opinion, and you get tired. Thereâ€™s no story here. Itâ€™s a million marriages. Each of you sees it a little differently. You get tired of seeing it a little differently. To be Simon and Garfunkel in the fifth year had me in a place where I needed a rest from Paul. It was killing me, all this duelling. But I never wanted to say good riddance to that charmed place. To me, the structure of duality had only just begun. I remain enamoured of that duo. How complementary their talents are, that duo.â€
One day when I am visiting Simon at the Brill Building, we go off to throw a baseball. Simon picks a guitar with his right hand, but on a baseball field he goes the other way. â€œThatâ€™s something I remember about my father,â€ he tells me. â€œI was five or six and we were having a catch. He got me a glove. A righty glove. Iâ€™d take it off to throw it back. Heâ€™d say, â€˜No, no. We do it this way.â€™ Eventually he came into the house and told my mother, â€˜Belle, we got a lefty!â€™ Thereâ€™s incredible pleasure in throwing a ball. Having a catch with your dad is having a conversation. As you throw the ball back and forth itâ€™s heavenly.â€
Simon has practised his guitar so much across his life that his left arm has been operated on for carpal tunnel syndrome. He has tendinitis in both of his elbows and neuropathic tingling in his hands. This means he can throw a ball outside only when itâ€™s really warm. On this chilly afternoon, when Simon gleefully announces that he has found us a place to play indoors, I have just come from a meeting and am wearing a tie and dress shoes, but Iâ€™ve never been able to resist that voice.
We leave the Brill Building and pass Colony Records, where, in a display window, Simon notices an old Elvis Presley show poster. Pointing to Presleyâ€™s belt, which is fastened off to the side, Simon says that because of Presley, as a teenager he wore his belts that same way. We get in the car and drive to a side street in the city, where his brother, Eddie Simon, has a membership at a health club located behind an unmarked black door. â€œYouâ€™re Eddieâ€™s brother!â€ the man at the desk says to Simon.
The gym in the club has mirrored walls, soft lighting, a wellness aura and many people who seem unsurprised to see the Kew Gardens Hills Southpaw out on the hardwood, breaking off sweeping curves. â€œDim in here,â€ Simon says, trying out his knuckler. Then he adds, â€œThrowingâ€™s not my game. Iâ€™m a hitter!â€
The thing about playing catch is that itâ€™s all rhythm. Very quickly, no matter whom you are throwing the ball with, your mind begins to drift. As Simon increases the velocity, I find myself thinking about why his music is so universal in its appeal, beloved by Englishmen and Africans, by old-school guys from Atlantic City and stockbrokers in Chicago, by an 80-year-old grandfather and his six-year-old granddaughter sitting next to him on the family piano bench as the old man bangs out â€˜The Sound of Silence.â€™ More than Dylan, more than Jagger and Richards, the melodies say that some things your parents like, you can like too. His half-heartbroken songs remind us that nobody is spared. Most people are in crazy motion, and just need a little something to calm them down.
Tossing the ball, Simon has a nice motion. Itâ€™s the only thing about him I ever see that comes over the top. â€œI reduce what Iâ€™m trying to do all the time,â€ he told me once. He was talking about his lyrics, how the joy and challenge for him is in the efficiency. He seemed to be saying that even if at first you are writing about your own life, by compressing your experiences to their very essence, they might mysteriously reopen into something that goes well beyond the songwriter.
â€œMake it as simple as you can,â€ he said. â€œTake a complex thing and make it as simple as you possibly can. Youâ€™re lucky if you ever attain it. What Iâ€™m interested in within art is beauty. The people who like what I do like beauty. If itâ€™s beautiful, that produces an openness of feeling and generosity. And it means youâ€™re vulnerable.â€